# Blue Jays at Yankees MLB Predictions

> Blue Jays lead the ALDS 2-0 over the Yankees. Game 3 shifts to New York as Rodón battles Bieber. See odds, picks, and expert betting tips.

Published 2025-10-06 · Updated 2026-04-22 · By [Rock Westfall](https://www.primesportsbook.com/author/rockwestfall/)

The regular season ended with the Toronto Blue Jays and New York Yankees tied for the American League East championship. Toronto won the tiebreaker and earned a wild card bye.

Meanwhile, the Yankees beat the Boston Red Sox in the wild card series. New York won the final two games after losing Game 1 to Boston.

Now the Blue Jays and Yankees will settle things once and for all in 2025.

On Tuesday night, Yankee Stadium will host Game 3 of the American League Division Series with the Yankees favored in [MLB betting odds](https://www.primesportsbook.com/sports/baseball/mlb/).

In the first two games at Toronto, the Blue Jays bombarded the Yankees with wins of 10-1 in Game 1 and 13-7 in Game 2.

## Blue Jays at Yankees Preview

On Tuesday, October 7, 2025, the New York Yankees will host the Toronto Blue Jays in Game 3 of the ALDS at Yankee Stadium, Bronx, NY. Game time is 8:08 p.m. ET with television coverage on FS1.

The probable starting pitcher for Toronto is right-hander Shane Bieber. In 2025, Biber was 4-2 with a 3.57 earned run average with a 1.02 WHIP. Bieber was on the disabled list most of the season. Finally, he was activated on August 22.

The probable starting pitcher for New York is left-hander Carlos Rodon. In 2025, Rodon was 18-9 with a 3.09 earned run average and 1.05 WHIP.

## Blue Jays at Yankees Predictions

- The Yankees are the most popular team on the board in the American League.

- New York consistently carries higher prices at home based on its brand and the mystique of Yankee Stadium.

- In a home playoff game against Toronto, New York won’t be as expensive as normal.

- New York was a solid home team this year and won two out of three at Yankee Stadium in the wild-card round.

- Toronto was not a reliable [MLB betting value](https://www.primesportsbook.com/sports/baseball/mlb/) on the road this year.

- In this situation, New York offers more value.

**Blue Jays at Yankees Best Bet:** New York Yankees

## Blue Jays at Yankees Betting Tips

- In the regular season, the Toronto Blue Jays were 94-68 and 40-41 on the road.

- Toronto was 86-71-5 over the total.

- The Blue Jays had MLB metrics of 4th for run production, 3rd for OPS, 11th for home runs, and 28th for stolen bases.

- Toronto ranked 19th for earned run average, 16th for WHIP, and 16th for bullpen ERA.

- George Springer led the Blue Jays in the regular season with 105 runs, 32 home runs, 84 runs batted in, and a .959 OPS.

- So far in the playoffs, Vladimir Guerrero has three runs, two home runs, and six RBI with a 1.933 OPS.

- In the 2025 season, the Yankees finished with a 94-68 record and a 40-31 home record.

- New York was 76-84-5 under the total.

- New York ranked 1st for run production, 1st for OPS, 1st for home runs, and 9th for stolen bases.

- New York ranked 14th for earned run average, 12th for WHIP, 24th for fewest errors committed, and 23rd for bullpen ERA.

- So far in five playoff games, Aaron Judge has not hit a home run after powering to 53 home runs in the regular season.

## Blue Jays at Yankees Head-to-Head and Key Stats

- In the series between Toronto and New York, the Blue Jays won 11 of the most recent 20 meetings.

- The Yankees and Blue Jays went under the total in only seven of their last 20 matchups.

- Specifically, at Yankee Stadium, the Yankees got the cash in eight of their most recent 11 games against the Blue Jays.

- Only six of the last 20 games between the Blue Jays and Yankees at Yankee Stadium went over the total.

- Toronto was one of the most profitable teams in 2025 at +1677 units on the money line and +1494 against the run line.

- Toronto was -69 money line units on the road.

- The Yankees finished -559 units on the moneyline and -162 against the run line.

- New York was +8 moneyline units at home.

Source: https://www.primesportsbook.com/gaming-insider/blue-jays-at-yankees-mlb-predictions/